One company, Downhole Emerging Technologies (DET), has turned to additive manufacturing (AM) to create solutions. The company recently of the American-Made Geothermal Manufacturing Competition, sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), for their innovative Diamond ETIP (Extreme Temperature Isolation Packer).
A packer is a mechanical device that is deployed and retrieved by wireline into a geothermal well to isolate specific zones of the well. It can be deformed to accurately fit the shape of the well—and is a key technology for harnessing geothermal power. But the packer needs to be able to withstand the extreme temperatures within the well.
Existing packer technologies in the industry have been adapted from the oil and gas sectors, which use rubber and plastics. These parts fall short in three ways: they aren’t rated for the heat in a geothermal well that can often exceed 200 degrees Celsius, they tend not to last more than a year and they are not easily deployed or retrieved. In addition, these components can be expensive.
DET set out to create a metal packer that could be easily deployed and retrieved. “We came up with a very intricate, crazy design that simply cannot be machined,” said Ken Havlinek, CEO of Downhole Emerging Technologies. “But it can be printed.”
DET’s packer is shaped like a large bracelet with features that allow it to deform, precisely and rapidly, into the shape required to create a seal in the mine shaft. Because of the complex internal features of the device—it’s not just a hollow ring—it could not be machined, molded or extruded using traditional manufacturing methods because of the complex internal features of the device.
But while conventional manufacturing methods weren’t suitable, DET found that 3D printing technologies were up to the task. Downhole partnered with Protolabs, a digital manufacturing specialist company, to print the part. In fact, the component was the largest Inconel largest Inconel additively manufactured part Protolabs has created to date.
One component of the packer is called the setting tool, which applies the force to deform the packer in order to set it in position or retract it. DET wanted to use as little energy as possible to set the packer in place as well as unset and retract the device—the smaller the amount of force required the better. Additive manufacturing allowed DET’s engineers to reduce the forces needed.
In fact, because existing setting tool systems could not generate the force needed to set a metal packer, DET originally set out to make its own custom setting tool that could apply the extremely high force that was required. However, the company started using additive manufacturing to create prototypes and iterate the design to reduce the amount of force the tool needed. Through this process the company landed on a design that applied force efficiently enough to enable the use of existing commercially available setting tool systems. According to Havlinek, reaching that point freed the company from having to do extensive work to design its own setting system: DET could now use setting tools that are already on the market.
“Once we started envisioning a solution that additive manufacturing could reach, it really opened the door to us getting very creative and finding ideas that allow this device to perform far better than it would have if we stuck with traditional manufacturing methods,” said Havlinek. “We designed it so it takes less force to compress it and stretch it while maintaining the exact same deformation and performance.”
One of the benefits of 3D printing that was of particular benefit was the fast turnaround time in creating and iterating prototypes. “Additive manufacturing can often turn a drawing into a prototype a lot faster than a machine shop can,” said Havlinek. “That was a really nice feature when you’re up against a tight time frame, on top o the fact that additive manufacturing can create parts that simply can’t be made any other way.”
DET determined that stainless metals would be the best option for the packer. “Any underground environment that's going to be involved in either oil and gas or now geothermal is going to have chemicals that corrode and do a pretty good job of destroying a lot of materials, including most metals,” said Havlinek. For that reason, the Diamond ETIP uses 17-4 PH stainless steel alloy, which has a high tensile strength and withstands corrosive effects up to high temperatures better than conventional stainless steel. The packer also uses Inconel and other nickel-based alloys, which are also corrosion-resistant. These alloys are all commonly used in additive manufacturing.
“Without additive manufacturing, we would not have been able to treat the parts like we did, we would have had to machine it in a different shape and it wouldn't have performed as well as it did.”
Additive manufacturing technologies are still fairly new in the geothermal sector, since much of the technology comes from oil and gas—another sector which has not seen widespread adoption of these techniques. Havlinek states that word has been getting around, though, with projects like DET’s partnership with Protolabs generating interest. “I do think there's a lot of opportunity for additive manufacturing, not just for the project we just finished, but for a lot of other projects,” he said. “I know there's plenty of opportunities out there.”
Winning the Geothermal Manufacturing Prize has undoubtedly helped spread the word. The competition brings together research labs, universities, incubators, entrepreneurs and 17 Department of Energy National Laboratories to identify opportunities for 3d printing technologies in the geothermal sector. The Geothermal Prize itself consists of a series of four progressive competitions to design and produce prototypes for use in the industry. “This DOE competition harnesses breakthroughs in additive manufacturing to help overcome barriers to widespread deployment of geothermal energy,” said Alejandro Moreno, Deputy Assistant Secretary for Renewable Power.
Not only do participants compete for cash prizes, they are given opportunities to tap into a network of experts in an extensive innovation ecosystem. “You need partners. You need other people that have the same common motivation but have potentially different skillsets, different backgrounds, different facilities,” said Havlinek. “I truly believe the company that isolates itself and tries to solve all the geothermal problems in front of us themselves are going to quickly be left behind.”
DET intends to use the $500,000 prize to ruggedize the packer and bring it to market over the next year. In particular, the company is looking at making further innovations to its packer. “That’s more money than we would need to finish this project and commercialize it,” said Havlinek. DET has more ideas on their whiteboard and will use the funding to move them forward.
Thanks to additive manufacturing technologies, and innovative products like the Diamond ETIP, the challenges of geothermal energy extraction look like they could be solvable, unlocking a significant new energy source.